周纪君,李远哲,陈珍,谭明军,刘馥齐

• 1:招商局重庆交通科研设计院有限公司

摘要(Abstract)：

为推动低空物流领域发展的深入研究，综述了近年来该领域的重要研究进展，围绕通导监保障体系、低空管理保障体系、低空飞行保障3个方面进行了系统性梳理。分析表明：1)当前发展的通感一体化技术、毫米波通信技术、“北斗”卫星导航系统、惯性导航、ADS-B技术等主流技术，虽能为低空物流配送提供精准可靠的通信与导航支撑，但仍存在着覆盖范围不足、稳定性受限等问题；2)低空空域管理聚焦于空域划分和航线规划，低空安全监管围绕着法律法规、运营安全监管等方面，低空飞行服务则主要以顺丰、京东等物流企业为主，但仍存在着低空空域管理尚不完善、安全监管难度大等问题；3)低空飞行保障研究重点聚焦于地方政策、规章制度、技术标准等方面，但缺乏细致的分类标准和技术管理规范；4)通过归纳和总结研究现状，提出了在技术创新、资源整合与协同管理等方面的对策建议，研究结果可供推动低空物流领域规模化、高质量发展参考。

关键词(KeyWords)： 低空物流;低空航空器;通导监一体化;空域管理;飞行服务;安全监管;飞行保障

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 周纪君,李远哲,陈珍,谭明军,刘馥齐

DOI: 10.13607/j.cnki.gljt.2025.03.022

参考文献(References)：

• [1]于荣权.低空经济中的空域管理与安全监管研究[J].成都航空职业技术学院学报,2024,40(3):75-80.YU Rongquan.Research on airspace management and safety supervision in low-altitude economy[J].Journal of Chengdu Aeronautic Polytechnic,2024,40(3):75-80.
• [2]王康伟.我国低空经济产业发展现状、问题及对策研究[J].产业创新研究,2024(15):49-51.WANG Kangwei.Research on the development status,problems and countermeasures of China′s low-altitude economic industry[J].Industrial Innovation,2024(15):49-51.
• [3]付道繁.5G-A通感一体技术在无人机飞控导航中的应用[J].电信快报,2024(11):16-19.FU Daofan.Application of 5G-A synaesthesia technology in UAV flight control and navigation[J].Telecom Letters,2024(11):16-19.
• [4]王剑.通感一体网络在低空经济中的应用[J].通信世界,2024(19):16-18.WANG Jian.Application of synaesthesia integrated network in low-altitude economy[J].Telecom World,2024(19):16-18.
• [5]金婧,王亚娟,马良,等.面向低空智联的通感一体技术[J].信息通信技术与政策,2024,50(11):54-62.JIN Jing,WANG Yajuan,MA Liang.Integrated sensing and communication for low-altitude network[J].Information and Communications Technology and Policy,2024,50(11):54-62.
• [6]许宁宁.探索通感一体低空经济等新应用场景[N].南方日报,2024-10-17(A06).XU Ningning.Explore new application scenarios such as synaesthesia,integrated low-altitude economy,etc[N].Nanfang Daily,2024-10-17(A06).
• [7]徐晓东,李岩,叶威,等.通信感知一体化应用场景、关键技术和网络架构[J].移动通信,2022,46(5):2-8.XU Xiaodong,LI Yan,YE Wei.Application scenarios,key technologies and network architecture of integrated sensing and communication[J].Mobile communications,2022,46(5):2-8.
• [8]宋杰,周建锋,王卫斌.低空智联网赋能低空经济的思考与探索[J].信息通信技术与政策,2024,50(11):28-32.SONG Jie,ZHOU Jianfeng,WANG Weibin.Thoughts and exploration on empowering low-altitude economy with low-altitude intelligent network[J].Information and Communications Technology and Policy,2024,50(11):28-32.
• [9]陈立,邱健熙.推动5G-A通感一体技术发展构筑低空经济坚实底座[J].新经济导刊,2024(7):36-41.CHEN Li,QIU Jianxi.Promote the development of 5G-Aintegrated sensing and communication technology building solid foundation for low-altitude economy[J].New Economy Weekly,2024(7):36-41.
• [10]梁狄,许芳,李雅琦,等.低空经济背景下城市区域轻小型物流无人机技术发展策略研究[J/OL].企业科技与发展,1-7[2025-02-05].LIANG Di,XU Fang,LI Yaqi,et al.Research on the development strategy of light and small logistics UAVtechnology in urban areas under the background of lowaltitude economy[J/OL].Enterprise Science And Technology&Development,1-7[2025-02-05].
• [11]YI W,LIU Y,BODANESE E,et al.A unified spatial framework for UAV-aided mm Wave networks[J].IEEETransactions on Communications,2019,67 (12):8801-8817.
• [12]SHI X,DENG N.Coverage probability of UAV-enabled millimeter wave communications in finite areas[C]//IEEE Wireless Communications and Networking Conference(WCNC).Nanjing:IEEE,2021:1-6.
• [13]卫海超,刘铭岳,张家红,等.城市无人机毫米波通信网络建模与性能分析[J].科学技术与工程,2021,21(30):12990-12996.WEI Haichao,LIU Mingyue,ZHANG Jiahong,et al.Modeling and performance analysis of unmanned aerial vehicle millimeter-wave networks in urban areas[J].Science Technology and Engineering,2021,21 (30):12990-12996.
• [14]C N BARATI,S A HOSSEINI,S RANGAN,et al.Directional cell discovery in millimeter wave cellular networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications,2015,14(12):6664-6678.
• [15]薛岳.面向无人机集群的毫米波通信关键技术研究[D].北京:北京邮电大学,2024.XUE Yue.Research on key technologies of millimeter wave communication for UAV swarm[D].Beijing:Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications,2024.
• [16]郑琳洁.毫米波通信中的无人机波束管理技术研究[D].深圳:深圳大学,2023.ZHENG Linjie.Research on UAV beam management technology in millimeter wave communication[D].Shenzhen:Shenzhen University,2023.
• [17]屈若锟,王致远,刘晔璐,等.面向城市空中交通的无人机视觉定位技术研究[J/OL].航空学报,1-16[2025-01-07].QU Ruokun,WANG Zhiyuan,LIU Yelu,et al.Research on UAV visual positioning technology for urban air mobility[J/OL].Journal of Aeronautics,1-16[2025-01-07].
• [18]张洪海,李姗,夷珈,等.城市低空航路规划研究综述[J].南京航空航天大学学报,2021,53(6):827-838.ZHANG Honghai,LI Shan,YI Jia,et al.Review on urban low-altitude air route planning[J].Journal of Nanjing University of Aeronautics&Astronautics,2021,53(6):827-838.
• [19]沈志宏.雷达、通信、导航技术在低空空域监管中发挥的作用[J].通讯世界,2019,26(11):47-48.SHEN Zhihong.The role of communication and navigation technology in the supervision of low-altitude airspace[J].Telecom World,2019,26(11):47-48.
• [20]何运成.北斗系统在我国民航领域应用现状及发展前景[J].卫星应用,2019(9):19-24.HE Yuncheng.The application status and development prospect of Beidou system in China′s civil aviation field[J].Satellite Applications,2019(9):19-24.
• [21]陈智也,孙杰,杨美群.“北斗”卫星导航系统在低空空域监管系统中的应用[J].通讯世界,2016(22):255-256.CHEN Zhiye,SUN Jie,YANG Meiqun.Application of"Beidou"satellite navigation system in low-altitude airspace supervision system[J].Telecom World,2016(22):255-256.
• [22]曾龙.面向城市空中交通无人机视觉导航方法研究[D].德阳:中国民用航空飞行学院,2022.ZENG Long.Research on visual navigation method for UAV for urban air mobility[D].Deyang:Civil Aviation Flight University of China,2022.
• [23]SHAN M,WANG F,LIN F,et al.Google map aided visual navigation for UAVs in GPS-denied environment[C]//2015 IEEE international conference on robotics and biomimetics.2015:114-119.
• [24]SHAN M,GAO Z,TANG Y,et al.Google map oriented robust visual navigation for MAVs in GPS-denied environment[M].Autonomy of Single UAV,2020.
• [25]PATEL B.Visual Localization for UAVs in Outdoor GPS-denied Environments[M].University of Toronto(Canada),2019.
• [26]JUREVICIUS R,MARCINKEVICUS V,?EIBOKAS J.Robust GNSS-denied localization for UAV using particle filter and visual odometry[J].Machine Vision and Applications,2019,30(7):1181-1190.
• [27]扈胜超,张阎.ADS-B技术在低空领域通用机载导航监视中的应用[J].中阿科技论坛(中英文),2021(6):108-110.HU Shengchao,ZAHNG Yan.Application of ADS-Btechnology in general airborne navigation and surveillance in low-altitude areas[J].China-Arab State Science and Technology Forum (Chinese and English Edition),2021(6):108-110.
• [28]覃睿,史娅琪,王明科.面向低空飞行安全监视的ADS-B地面站空间布局规划方法[J].重庆交通大学学报(自然科学版),2018,37(7):100-105.QIN Rui,SHI Yaqi,WANG Mingke.Spatial distribution programming method of ADS-B ground station oriented to low altitude flight safety[J].Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University (Natural Sciences),2018,37 (7):100-105.
• [29]王尔申,佟刚,庞涛.低空空域通用航空飞机机载导航监视终端设计[J].电讯技术,2015,55(5):522-526.WANG Ershen,TONG Gang,PANG Tao.Design of an airborne navigation surveillance terminal for general aviation aircraft in low altitude airspace[J].Telecommunication Engineering,2015,55(5):522-526.
• [30]李鹏举,杜绍岩,冉阳,等.低空监视雷达探测无人机目标关键技术分析[C]//第四届无人系统高峰论坛(USS 2024)论文集.北京:航天时代飞鸿技术有限公司,北京遥测技术研究所,2024:4.LI Pengju,DU Shaoyan,RAN Yang,et al.Analysis of key technologies for low altitude surveillance radar detection of drone targets[C]//Proceedings of the 4th Unmanned Systems Summit Forum (USS 2024).Beijing:Aerospace Times Feihong Technology Co.,Ltd.,Beijing Institute of Telemetry Technology,2024:4.
• [31]RUI C,MARTINS P,BATISTA J.Exploiting the Circulant Structure of Tracking-by-detection with Kernels[C]//European Conference on Computer Vision.Springer-Verlag,2012:702-715.
• [32]GIRSHICK R,DONAHUE J,DARRELL T,et al.Rich feature hierarchies for accurate object detection and semantic segmentation[C]//IEEE Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition.Columbus,United States,2014:580-587.
• [33]DAI J,LI Y,HE K,et al.R-FCN:object detection via region-based fully convolutional networks[C]//IEEEComputer Vision and Pattern Recognition.Nevada,United States,2016:2514-2530.
• [34]高捷.低空空域规划与交通仿真技术发展和应用[J].科技和产业,2024,24(23):230-235.GAO Jie.Development and application of low-altitude airspace management and traffic simulation technology[J].Science Technology and Industry,2024,24 (23):230-235.
• [35]傅惠,崔煜,赵佳虹,等.低空无人机物流配送研究与应用综述[J/OL].工业工程,1-13[2025-02-05].FU Hui,CUI Yu,ZHAO Jiahong,et al.A review of research and applications in low-altitude logistics and delivery using unmanned aerial vehicles[J/OL].Industrial Engineering Journal,1-13[2025-02-05].
• [36]谢华,韩斯特,尹嘉男,等.城市低空无人机飞行计划协同推演与优化调配方法[J].航空学报,2024,45(19):263-285.XIE Hua,HAN Site,YIN Jianan,et al.Cooperative deduction and optimal allocation method for urban low altitude UAV flight plan[J].Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,2024,45(19):263-285.
• [37]李楠,辛春阳.基于聚类-Floyd-遗传算法的“车辆+无人机”城市物流配送路径优化[J].科学技术与工程,2024,24(21):9186-9193.LI Nan,XIN Chunyang.Urban logistics distribution routing optimization of"vehicle-drone"based on clustering-Floyd-genetic algorithm[J].Science Technology and Engineering,2024,24(21):9186-9193.
• [38]HONG I,KUBY M,MURRAY A T.A range-restricted recharging station coverage model for drone delivery service planning[J].Transportation Research Part C:Emerging Technologies,2018,90:198-212.
• [39]JIN Z,NG K K H,ZHANG C,et al.Arisk-averse distributionally robust optimisation approach for dronesupported relief facility location problem[J].Transportation Research Part E:Lo-gistics and Transportation Review,2024,186:103538.
• [40]胡大伟,张世鹏,刘慧甜,等.应急响应初期“卡车-无人机”联合配送路径问题[J].长安大学学报(自然科学版),2024,44(1):105-119.HU Dawei,ZHANG Shipeng,LIU Huitian,et al.Routing problem of truck-drones joint distribution in initial stage of emergency response[J].Journal of Chang′an University(Natural Science Edition),2024,44(1):105-119.
• [41]XU X,XIE C,LUO Z,et al.A multi-objective evolutionary al-gorithm based on dimension exploration and discrepancy evolution for UAV path planning problem[J].Information Sciences,2024,657:119977.
• [42]季冠仲.我国通用航空领域低空空中交通管理问题研究[D].济南:山东财经大学,2024.JI Guanzhong.Research on Low Altitude Air Traffic Management in China′s General Aviation Industry[D].Ji′nan:Shandong University of Finance and Economics,2024.
• [43]李振华.城市低空交通管理体系构建研究[J].中国设备工程,2022(16):7-9.LI Zhenhua.Research on the construction of urban lowaltitude traffic management system[J].China Plant Engineering,2022(16):7-9.
• [44]姜依静.协同决策在空中交通流量管理中的应用[J].中国航务周刊,2023(23):70-72.JIANG Yijing.Application of collaborative decisionmaking in air traffic flow management[J].China Aviation Weekly,2023(23):70-72.
• [45]戴秉翰.民用无人机法律监管问题研究[D].南京:南京信息工程大学,2022.DAI Binghan.Research on legal supervision issues of civil drones[D].Nanjing:Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,2022.
• [46]金伟,尚勇.中国无人机安全监管[J].科技导报,2019,37(14):66-77.JIN Wei,SHANG Yong.The safety supervision of unmanned aircraft systems in China[J].Science&Technology Review,2019,37(14):66-77.
• [47]涂天鹤.无人机物流规范运营发展的策略研究[D].南昌:南昌航空大学,2021.TU Tianhe.Research on thedevelopment strategy of UAVlogistics standard operation[D].Nanchang:Nanchang Hangkong University,2021.
• [48]刘力.低空经济中的安全监管和风险控制策略研究[J].民航管理,2024(6):84-88.LIU Li.Research on safety supervision and risk control strategies in low-altitude economy[J].Civil Aviation Management,2024(6):84-88.
• [49]蒋雪萤.民用无人机飞行监管法律制度研究[D].重庆:西南大学,2020.JIANG Xueying.Research on the legal system of civil UAV flight supervision[D].Chongqing:Southwestern University,2020.
• [50]管祥民,许东松.低空飞行服务保障体系建设新内涵及人才培训体系构建思考[J].民航管理,2024(6):19-23.GUAN Xiangmin,XU Dongsong.New connotation of lowaltitude flight service support system and thoughts on talent training system[J].Civil Aviation Management,2024(6):19-23.
• [51]宋志勇.高质量建设低空飞行服务保障体系[J].大飞机,2024(5):11-13.SONG Zhiyong.High-quality construction of low-altitude flight service guarantee system[J].Large Aircraft,2024(5):11-13.
• [52]罗涛.低空飞行信息化服务应用及市场前景分析[J].空运商务,2024(9):14-18.LUO Tao.Application of low-altitude flight information services and market prospects analysis[J].Air Transport Business,2024(9):14-18.
• [53]全国首张目视飞行航图发布---中国民航通用航空信息服务平台上线[J].空运商务,2019(4):33-34.The first visual flight navigation chart in china releasedlaunch of the general aviation information service platform[J].Air Transport&Business,2019(4):33-34.
• [54]于金杨,张吉,李皛,等.空地一体通信网络构筑低空经济底座[J].信息通信技术与政策,2024,50(11):11-17.YU Jinyang,ZHANG Ji,LI Xiao,et al.Air-ground integrated communication network builds the foundation for low-altitude economy[J].Information and Communications Technology and Policy,2024,50 (11):11-17.